idk..i havent heard them...but i think they should use Roberts....because he plays Edward in the movie and it would fit him better i think.....

roberts version would be nice, he plays the character so he knows the love edward feels for bella, so i would think his version would better portray their love and show how much she means to him. i mean im sure carters is good too, but i just think roberts would be better

Roberts will totally work...he is way talented and coming from him will be nice.

Robert Pattison all the way!

i am torn for two reasons. 1: it would be so cute if robbert wrote it and he would know it well and play it the best... but the other guy knows his stuff and can do really well. 2: i acually wrote a song for it, but i havnt sent it in yet. i guess it is a high hope for an 11 year old, but my teachers say it is really good, and so does the teen music center. idk

well, i dont really know. i know that rob is very talented but again, im sure that the new guy is too. roberts version was very long and did take up most of the scene. but also...it makes the lullaby more true. but because robs version is not being used i think that they SHOULD use it at another part in the movie. maybe play during the closing credits [spot is already taken but hopefully they can make room] or maybe at the opening credits...im not sure what is supposed to be playing then...but i think it would give insight to the upcoming events if it were there. my over all idea is to use both at some point in the movie but name only one as "bella's lullaby"

I agree with Tiffany F. I still think they should use Yiruma's song, 'River Flows in You'. That is a very beautiful and calming song, and it is very fitting for a lullaby. My friends and I have already fallen into the habit of calling it Bella's Lullaby.

yea im with Larrianne B , i have to hear them first ... i mean i think it would mean more if they used rob's but which ever one is better thats the they will use... it doesnt really matter to me .

WHAT!?? noo! they should definitely put robert's lullabye in the movie. it would be soo much cuter if he wrote it.

...

where can i find the songs at?...i haven't heard them so i want to debate on which one will sound somewhat right

deff roberts

I say use roberts i have both verions on my ipod and i prefer his if you want to find both go to limewire
i also think its more aproppriate because robert is edward and edward originaly wrote the song

I say use Roberts

USE ROBERT.S PLEASE!!!!!

use roberts!!
i heard roberts!!
its amazing!!

use it!!!
rob is edward, edward is robert...
edward wrote the lulluby!
us his, it will be so much better!!!

where are the diff. versions!!
i must know!!

I would LOVE to listen to both of them where can I find them?
And some of you people OMG if the only reason why you picked Roberts is because you "love" him you make me ill!

exactly, right? where do i find these lullabies you speak of? TO YOUTUBE!

Where do I go to listen to the two different versions.

i think they should use robert pattisons
because i love it i also love robert. he is so cute!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I think they should use Rob's.. It's more personal then..
Rob is Edward and Edward wrote the lullaby..
I hope they use Rob's song "I'll be your lover too" I absolutly love it!

i think that they should use rober pattinsons because he plays edward in the movie and edward composese bellas lullaby

Halle K. I totally agree with you.

If they screw this up I think me and you and anyone else who thinks this too should go after them -nods-

"the river flows in you"... by yiruma!!!!

Sory for the reckon typo :)

To decide, i would really need to see the movie... you know hear the song in context. I recoken whichever one they don't use they should put as a deleted sceen or bonus at the end or something?

I really hope that this is bella's lullaby:
http://www.youtube.com/wa tch?v=3c6hlvEv-...
The song was so beautiful it made me cry! I think that THAT song should be it.