Glory was a twit! A spoiled brat airhead with a baby's temper. Drucilla rocked with her now-she's-evil, now-she's-insane personality.

Glory - she was just a really fun character

Glory!

I vote DAWN...
What do you mean DAWN wasn't technically an evil-spawn puppet from a disused hell dimension. Really? I was convinced that she was...

It's totally all about Glory. Hardcore all the way. I'm surprised that she wasn't an option. Crazy hell goddess who gives everyone a run for their money, and is indirectly the cause of the death of Buffy from which return is much more complicated. That one is pretty obvious.

the best Buffy villian was the Voice Eaters in the episode of Hush.

If were talking somebody who wasn't a major player, then I'd definitely have to go with The Gentlemen from Hush. The creepy silence, not to mention those smiles even thought they were removing your heart. *shivers* They definitely have my vote.

I think Angelus has it hands down. He always went for the psychological part first. I mean he drove Drusilla crazy...and then he turned her. Plus, that part where he first turned evil in Innocence with the girl and the smoke from the cigarette. I mean...how much more bad ass can an evil villian be?

Glory and Caleb missing?
Not to mention The Mayor (kudos for the Evil Mister Rogers bit...I might have to put that on a shirt).
And come on...the demon in "Once More With Feeling"?
He was straight hardcore, if only for the one episode in which he appeared.

Although, out of the above, Faith had my vote.
She's pretty much crazy, and I'd leave her well enough alone.

What about Glory?

Caleb was awesome, too.

The Mayor. He was like an evil Mr. Rogers

Glory

I vote for Glory!!
Angelus was crazy/evil and loved it. Drusilla was crazy AND evil and hot!
Spike was the original, often imitated but never duplicated BIG BAD!!
Sweet was even pretty cool with the singing and the dancing.
But the best of the worst, is Season Five's Glory!! Yes, The Master killed Buffy but she was able to come back with relative ease. But when Glory killed her, it was for good, or at least until the following season. Glory was the most attractive villian, not the most intelligent villian, but she effectively won. She did not live to see her victory and the Buffy did prevent the world from being sucked into hell, but she was the reason Buffy died! She tortured Spike, drove Tara insane and killed Buffy. Winner in my book.

OH!!! OR CALEB!!! he was some scary ****!! Or Adam... what's worse than a modern day Frankenstine?

The Trio was straight badass. What's better than a bunch of nerds who think they're all powerful and actually would have a shot at doing it? Sure they had issues like when they would chicken out or made it obvious that they were following Buffy, but they were adorable! Andrew did start tugging at my heart in the last season though. Especially when he killed Jonathan and then had to live with it. Warren was the best though. He was the one that wouldn't chicken out when he had an evil plan. Plus it was pretty kickass when Willow kills him.

I'd have to go with Dark Willow or Glory. Willow, because she was someone that Buffy could never kill. Angelous/Angel, she did. While she loved him, she got *there*. With Willow, I don't think she could ever bring herself to kill her. Glory, because I remember when watching, *I* didn't know how they were gonna beat her. She's the only 'bad' to have given me pause. Plus, she was responcible for Buffy's temperory demise. I think that's gotta count for something.

ok at first i would say spike cause it seemed likely but i relized they are equals then i would have put the master cause hey really did kill her but he wasn't worthy enough i would never put angelus why cause she did what she had to do and sent him to hell soul and all......... so i choose glory or dark willow why because glory a god created so much drama and actually killed buffy for more then 30 sec and dark willow well she is just great i know buffy would have to many emotions to actually kill willow and dark willow has to much power to let buffy even think of killing her :)

I gotta go with Dru, because I actually met Juliet Landau - so she gets my vote!

Dru, because bitch is crazy!

The love, hate, lust, then once again love & abandon relationship definitely makes Angelus a more likely candidate.

Angeles for sure is number one IMO...I think he did the most damage to Buffy especially emotionally! And if he ever came back he still would go after her first and torture her and everyone she loves! Caleb was really creepy and strong but his power wasn't his own and Glory was a Hell God so of course she was a great villian but in the end she lost like everyone else. I don't know if I would consider "The First" a villian more of an prescence.But Buffy will never forget what Angeles did to her because of what they shared.

uhhhhh.did we Forget the master..and the first..LOL...but over all..SPIKE RULEs!!! At his best his chaotic portrayal of spike was Genius. SPIKE RULES always!! No one will ever forget his character, he now has a life of his own.

I voted other and i vote for Glory because she is so badass.

What is with Spike , Dru and Darla? They weren't that bad. Darla was barely a smudge on Buffy. She was more of an Angel character. Glory should be on the list as well as Evil Willow. You could add the trio of evil dorks but they were more annoying than anything.

Angel was pretty aweful when he was evil but OH MY GOD! Caleb, I can't believe I forgot about him. The creepiest villain ever.

I'd have to say the best/creepiest/baddest villian of all was Caleb. That bad boy was just plain evil. I whooped and hollered when Buffy finally cut him in half!!
Of the ones listed, I'd say The First, then Angelus. So many villians to choose from!

Caleb's the best, by far. When he breaks the slayer-to-be's neck, another slayer cries out "No!" and he sneers "Yes!" that was probably the creepiest moment on the whole show.