Get Widget

Edward Vs. Jacob

93 Votes
  • Start Date:
    10-29-2008
  • Last Vote:
    4-28-2009

Description:

Which Twilight man do you like more? We've read the books, so who did you want Bella to end up with Jacob Black (former best friend & werewolf) or Edward Cullen (former boyfriend & vampire)?

or who do you just like the most?

I personally love Jacob more but I'm glad that Bella chose Edward, because what kind of mad series would it be if they didn't end up togther! :].

83%
8%
10%
Tell a FriendCreate a CampaignBookmark
EDWARD!!!!!!!!!!!

EDWARD

god i hate jacob,
MUCHLY.

yes i would love to live like a blood sucker forever
:)

TEAM EDWARD HECKZ YA!!!!!!

and another thing..all of you girls who are all like..OMFG EDWAARD DAAAAWWWWWWWW!!!!!..calm it down yo lol..you and i both know that the only reason you like edward is cuz hes the main character and and and that bell describes him as perfect ..and iv noticed lately that in high school relationships arent going well and you girls need something to dream about..a perfect man..and maybe yes edward is perfect..but no human is perfect...so get ahold of reality and accually put your self in bellas shoes and think ..would u really want to live like a blood sucker?...forever?...

ok im a guy so coming from all men jacob is by far better for bella ..hes better period..look at the facts edward ran away in the second book cuz he thought that would be better for her...who was there to stay with her the whole time knowing that bella loved edward? jacob...jacon even pulled a really gutsy move by kissing bella knowing he might have to battle with cullen...but hes so inFATUATED..AND OR IN LOVE WITH BELLA HE DIDNT CARE..EDWARD LIVES OFF LOGIC AND JACOB lives off instinct..plus jacob is more human than edward ..now i havent read breaking dawn yet so i dont know if bella becomes a blood sucker but if she were to choose jacob in eclipse..she would live a normal life while dying like the rest of us..without watching herself get old while some one she loves never ages...jacob doesnt age..but he can if he gives up the lycan inside him..there for...jacob is better

i completely agree with anglea Taylor is great for Jacob they shouldnt replace him!!!

PS katie r got it totally right...that is exactly y i am team switzerland

i am definately team switzerland! i really love edward but jacob can sometimes be really sweet! i think he got really stupid in the second and part of the third book, but i still love him!
and speaking of which who else thinks taylor lautner SHOULD NOT be replaced in new moon!!! i certainly dont think so! this micheal copon guy needs just go die or something (well not die but not get the job) because i dont want him playing my jacob!!!

Team Jacob because JACOB DIDN'T LEAVE. <3

;]

tottal hottie all Edward I'm obssesd everything I do is for and about Edward Cullen<3333

yayaya EDWARD MY MAN!!!!! he's mine hands off TEAM EDWARD and don't forget BELLA<33333333

I hate you Jacob keep on dreaming Eward is theone for Bella.

i honestly have to say a tie!!!! edward is ment for bella he is nice careful HOTT and protective... jacob on the other hand is fun anoying...well he is sort of like a anoying fun happy new puppy!

JACOD IS A BEEEEEEEEEPPPPPPPPP AN********************************* EDWARD IS PERFECT!!!!!

i am glad bella is marring edward.

Jacob is a ****...

Edward is perfect.

Team Edward till i die

team edward all the way. who would support a dog . jake is so annoying
go team edward

Ok so for me it's a tie....honestly I love both Jake and Edward. Edward is Bella's SOUL MATE we all kno that, she's in love with him and he's in love with her and they were just meant for each other. BUT she does love Jake-not the same way as Edward i kno-Jake was there for her when she was broken. He helped her put herself back together. In Bella's words Jake was her own "personal sun". I love Jake for what he did for her, how he helped her when she was alone and needed him. And like Bella said he's like family, like a brother. Of course that's not how Jake saw her and I felt REALLY bad for him about that. But now he has Reneesme so he's ok. I'm rambling...I just want to defend Jake because he really is a good person. Edward is HOT and Perfect and who wouldn't love him?! And he doesn't need defending. So for me it's TEAM EDWARD/JACOB! For different reasons but still I love them both!! Sorry for rambling :-)

TEAM EDWARD FOREVAH~!!!!...hahaha...

um jake is annoying...he can be soso every once in a while but mostly annoying i have no idea how bella could fallin luv with him who in hells name would. sure hes her sun but that was when edward was u know... anyways it may have left a mark on her but why did she have to fall in luv with him its fine to be buddys but that is all...sure being there when edward wasnt was nice and it cheered her up but still jake can be a total ass sometimes and imprinting on renesmee was a total twist but being buddys with him would be exciting. i hope he lives fairly well or he could just go to hell...I myself would never fall in luv with him unless hell froze over... but thats my opinion and i hope others agree with me...would i fall in luv with him if hell froze over?? anyways luv twilight Go Team Edward cant wait for the movie and Stephenie Meyers Work is Awesome!!

you people who voted for a tie or Jacob have got to be insane!!! TEAM EDWARD ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!

TEAM EDWARD FOR LIFE!
OMG he could have his way with me.
why did this have to be a fictional book?
WHHHHHY?!!

What's on Bella's mind when she think that she fall in love with Jacob??? It's totally wrong! Just because Jacob makes her feel better, it doesn't mean that she must be fall in love with him! You can not love everyone who can make you laugh or smile right?? If I am on Bella's position, I will give all my heart, mind, n feeling only to EDWARD!! With no even one little spot of doubt on it. and without thinking any longer, I'll agree to married with him and turning myself into vampire! Go Edward!! it doesn't mean that i hate Jacob..but..please don't disturb Edward n Bella because they're meant to be together..

EDWARD DUHHH !!!
OMG OMG I LOVEE HIM !!
i wish i could have him for myself
i think jacob is a jerk sometimes and idk he deserves to be the nanny xDD
lmao omg edward is amazinggg and soooo hot !!!
TEAM EDWARD FOR LIFE BABYYY !!! :]

omg. this is really hard to chose. i think if i was in bellas position i wouldve chos edward but when the books were being written i also kinda wahted her to end up with jacob. i LOVE them both and they are both just so perfect in different ways. I LOVE TWILIGHT!!!

Okay, personally.. I don't really
like Jacob very much.
I mean he is a nice boy, and i
and happy that he was there for
Bella throughout New Moon, but he
is a bit too immature. For instance,
if Bella were to ever tell Edward
she didnt want to be with him anymore,
he would be devistated, obviously.
But, he would let her be. But, not
Jacob, he has to just make things
harder for her... and if he really
loved her as much as he said he did,
he would have let her be with edward in
peace in Eclipse and Breaking Dawn. But, this is for obvious reasons, he is MUCH MUCH younger than
Edward and he is a bit childish, and it shows.

I am so happy she ended up with Edward!!! Jacob is sweet...but, 2 b honest, I don't think Edward could evr be without Bella and Vice-Versa...Thats true love....

I'm so glad she ended up with Edward. jacob was a great friend to her when she was in a time of need, but he also screwed with her mind repeatedly when he was upset. He was more into the leaving her behind to 'go have fun killing the vamps' but Edward always made sure she was safe, someone was with her, and he'd prefer to be the one to keep her safe. He seemed more selfless, always wanted to make her happy-not true for jacob. So Edward is def the better choice.

Loading People...