Jacob black deserves more than a pat on the back and a massive almost death experience from cullen (for kissing bella). Ed ran away in new moon cuz he thought it would be better for bella. but j.b stayed and pulled bells into the light.

Edward is perfect in looks and is what every girl dreams of..reads minds..and is super strong and fast.

Jacob is more pushy than cullen..is a werewolf.always warm..isnt afraid of a stupid damned bloodsucker

Edward can never die naturally....freaks out at the smell of blood..can sneeze on some one and they explode out of his brute strength

Jacob has to share his thoughts with other werewolves making secrets impossible..tends to kiss taken women (lol)

In my opinion jacob is better because he stayed with bella plus their childhood friends they kinda have history.

Who do you think is better?