I also think that Karen David should play Leah!

definatly noooooooot!!!

noooooooooooooooooooooo

NO!!! I think Vanessa Hudgens has no talent! She should not play the role! I mean the movies are pretty bad already but seriously! If she has any role in it, it will be a whole lot worse!

HELL NO!!!! Vanessa & Dakota are going to **** up the movie!! NO WAY, NO HOW!!!!

If she gets the role, I'm going to pretend Twilight never existed, and I'm dead serious.

KAREN DAVID SHOULD PLAY LEAHH !

they already fucked up new moon, which pisses me off to no end but i already bitched so this will be short. so shes pretty and all but shes not ment for this role, to be honest i don't really like her that much, and i've seen ppl that should do this role and will do it better than her. so absolutley not or that will be really upsetting with the stuff like jb on the new moon soundtrack ! BARF and edward not even leaving and twisating bella and jacobs relationship, its all wrong and im the biggest twihard out there and i know the books will be better but if there going to make books based on the movie then they should use the books ideas not change the whole thing!!!! i swear there going to have torched mobs coming after them with the way things are going ... but i know no matter if its really spoiled, i'll be really disappointed but i'll still love it cause its twilight and twilights life ! but if this **** can be prevented - PREVENT IT !

HELLL NOOOO!!! she will ruin the whole movie!!!!!!

gee... she'd spoil the WHOLE movie! new moon is the bomb and she cant kill it!

Vanessa??!!!! NOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! no way!

NO NO NO NO NO it would ruin the whle movie she wouldnt even fit the frickin part NOOOOOO

Leat stay away from all hannah montana, high school musical and anything else that would fall into that category

jesus christ, what an idea, i can't imagine that stupid irritating bimbo as leah,..

oh boy loool...vanessa has that annoying voice, and that kind of thing i can't even describe xD oh I am so sweet but I am a fake...she can even be a great person I don't know her so I am not going to say things like if I would know her, I am just saying what it seems. But, for all I said,I don't think she fits leah role, leah doesn't have that sweetness and she doesn't seem to be like a child and i really don't see vanessa as a good actress, at least not yet, and vanessa is too known in now days...so no...no no no. I wish best of luck to vanessa in her life and in her career, like I wish to every one of them because I "know" how difficult is to follow dreams and fight for them, and I know that people can be very evil, even more than what I was in the beggining of my comment lol, but like I said, It's what it seems, I didn't said she is. Kisses

NNNNNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! NO! NO! NO! I DO NTO WANT THIS STUPID ACTRESS RUINING THE MOVIE AND FURTHER MORE IF SHE IS IN IT (which i have heard that she isn't going to be) THEN I AM BOYCOTTING NEW MOON!!!!!!!

SHE IS GOING TO **** UP THE BEST BOOK OUT OF ALL THREE IF SHE IS THE ONE TO PLAY HER!!!! LEAH HAS ATTITUDE HUDGENS IS TOO NICE TO PLAY THE ROLE!!! WHO EVER PLAYS LEAH HAS TO BE A BITCH NOT A PUSHOVER!!!

NOOOOOOOOOOOO! she will ruin the WHOLE movie.

NOOOOOOOOOOOO! she will ruin the WHOLE movie

NO!!!!!!!! it would ruin it! Dear god PLEASE NO!

NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NOOOOOOOO VANESSA!!!! she is soooo not the right choice to play leah clearwater.... I think Lucy Hale is a lot better! Vanessa is a horrible choice and besides Vanessa is tooo prissy and girly HORRRRRRIBBBBLLLLEEEE!!!!!!!! NO VANESSA EVER! she will ruin all that is holy!

i think they will ruin the movie because first of all vanessa plays disney movies which suck to death and i think dakota wil be a bad choice to because she also is too yound and yound actors can be real brats also they both play in little jid show plus they are BAD actors!!!

Vanessa and Dakota are horrible choices for the parts of Leah and Jane. Honestly, has MTV lost all taste? (not that they had much to begin with) Seriously, My friends and I outraged at the concideration of them in the movie.

Vanessa would be terrible for the part! She's not right for the part, and she's a bad actress anyway, like in high school musical. She would just ruin the twilight movies forever! I swear i will die if she becomes Leah. Leah needs to be someone more hard core. Vanessa would just ruin everything about twilight.

This movie will be ruined if either Vanessa or Dakota Fanning are in it. They are trying to make this a big production with the hottest stars to make it more popular and it won't work. They should just get the right people for the part not the most popular. Leah is supposed to be tough and Vanesa is a mousy little twit... sorry but its true and yeah not right for the part. Stephenie Meyer obviously has no say in her own movie because iknow she wouldn't agree with the choices they are makeing in the casting. I just hope all of the stuff that im hearing is just rumors and not true. if any of this happens i don't think i will even want to see the movie.

hey its me again---FOR THE LOVE OF EDWARD NO!!!!

NONONONONONONONONONONONONO!!!!!She will ruin the movie and i will refuse to watch it!!!I hate...*shudder*...her and i hate...*double shudder*...High School Musical and she would ruin the movie and she would ruin the movie and she would ruin the movie!!!!NONONONONONONOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!

NONONONONONONONONONONONONONO!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!I will refuse to watch the movie if Vanessa Anne Hudgens getShes to be Leah!!!!!NO!She is terrible!!Bad actress!!bad!!!nonononononoNO!!!!she will ruin the movie!!

Vanessa is too sweet to play the role of Leah. No way.

JUST LIKE WITH MADONNA.. SHE WILL RUIN THE MOVIE