Blu-ray vs. HD DVD

6714 Votes
  • Start Date:
    11-20-2006
  • Last Vote:
    1-3-2009

Issue:

Microsoft, Sony and dozens of other large corporations have spent years NOT agreeing on a standard format for the next generation DVD. The result: two separate and incompatible formats are being offered to consumers. Eventually, like Betamax and VHS before them, one will win and one will lose. As of now, which one will win and which one will lose is uncertain. What is certain is that consumers will lose. Why? Some consumers will buy the losing format and end up with obsolete equipment. Many more consumers will buy nothing until after there is a clear winner - and prices will remain high until a mass market is developed.

Belief:

It is our belief that we the consumers can determine the winner in this format war. How will we do this? By having YOU vote for the format you prefer to win (Click here or on "Comparison between Blu-ray and HD DVD" link in the "Learn More" section to the left to see a comparison between the two formats). Then we all agree to buy the format that wins the vote. OK, it's as much a social experiment as a consumer stand. But our goal is clear - push the losing format to drop out. Let's take control! WHY DID YOU VOTE AS YOU DID? Share your thoughts in the forum below.
58%
Blu-ray
41%
HD DVD
Tell a FriendCreate a CampaignBookmark
Cast Your Vote
Forum Discussion for Blu-ray vs. HD DVD

My 48" HD Plasma already shows more than I need to see on the actors' faces with HD DVD. I really don't care enough about an extra pock mark showing to run down and get Blu-rays to replace all my DVD players.

See you in the pile along with Betamax and Firewire!

People, if you thinking Bluray is a latest successor or winner on these decades you,re really wrong again.
because what happend when hd-dvd dropout by Toshiba but why hd dvd sales is still alive again? sales more than bluray, mind you..
http://format warcentral.com/index.php/20...

Blu-ray sight and sound quality are unbelievable. For those of you that are skeptical, there's no better movie than Transformers to make you a believer.

On 1080p, the picture is crystal clear, the colors are vibrant, and the sound is amazing, I swear you can practically feel those freakin' robots.

Full of good bonus features that update in real-time (BD-Live capabilities). Plus Michael Bay talks about how they took each Transformer from toy to movie star.

You can find out more at www.tr ansformersmovie.com

Jeff, TF

i've seen both, and Blu-ray is the one that is sitting in my living room.

HD is the biggest comercial lie ever told, a DVD upscale to 720p or another resolution looks almost the same as a Blueray or HD DVD, the look really really good, and pretty much everyghing plays them (on the cars, computers, and all video game console) Blueray will be a considerable good format in 4-5 years, for now DVD is good, and DVDDL can storage movies in 720p format which is HD too, DVD will rule for the next 4 year, HD is too expensive for the public, first is the TV, then the Player, than the HD audio system, that alone is almost 2000 dollars if you really want to get total HD (1080P) again is a comercial lie to sell all those devices.

I for one am glad that Blu-ray won. All the HDDVD supporters kept saying that the higher bit rates and more capacity was useless. Here is part of a review of the Blu-ray release of Top Gun from Hi-def Digest. It reads:
Paramount offers a wealth of audio options on the Blu-ray of 'Top Gun': Dolby TrueHD 5.1 Surround (48kHz/24-bit, identical to the previous HD DVD), French and Spanish dubs in Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround (640kbps), and best of all, a DTS-HD Lossless Master Audio 5.1 Surround (48kHz/24-bit) that's exclusive to this Blu-ray. With bitrates noticeably higher than the TrueHD, the DTS-MA is the clear winner -- it's a pretty sizable leap in quality.Loudness is noticeably stronger on the DTS-MA right out of the gate, but even after volume level matching, clarity and depth of sound are superior over the TrueHD (which is no slouch on its own). The subwoofer delivers excellent bursts of low bass, that hold quite tight with only the deepest rumblings flattening out a bit. Surrounds are lively and engaged during the aerial dogfight sequences. Rears have noticeable heft, with smoother imaging on the DTS-MA. although imaging may be a tad smoother on the latter.

Even non-action scenes have some pronounced atmosphere, which isn't always the case on older catalog titles. Dynamics have great punch, with the DTS-MA really impressing me with how much more pronounced peaks and valleys sound. I still wish the pop/rock tunes were bled a bit more to the surrounds (the score is superior here in terms of bleed), but that's indicative of the original sound design. Despite the increased loudness of the DTS-MA track, I had little problem with dialogue, which is clear and generally well-positioned in the mix. 'Top Gun' sounded quite good before on HD DVD, but I found this Blu-ray and the DTS-MA track to be a surprising improvement.

Hi
There is another HD format called HD-VMD(HD Versatile Multilayer Disk) getting ready to burst upon the scene. It is a low-cost red laser technology, as already available in DVD players that achives HD by providing multilayered diskspace to reach resolution upto 1920x1080 pixels, conventionally known as 1080p. Currently it provides diskspace of 30 GB and promises to increase the layers to provide a storage space of upto 200 GB. It provides upto 7.1 sorround sound channels that includes Dolby Digital Plus and is fully backward compatible with existing DVDs, CDs etc upscaling DVDs to the near resolution of the magical 1080p. The product's USP is its incredible low price considering that one of the two players currently retail at $150 apiece. The top bosses in the company have claimed that even if they retail the player at $90 apiece they would still make a profit which Blu-ray can never achieve. Ofcourse, the Blue-ray people have countered it. The only difficulty expressed by the company is pursuading major Hollywood studios to agree to bring out software in the format. They are even trying to convince the Mumbai Film Industry to adopt the technology while embrassing HD. The company wants to survive alongside the existing HD format as a lowcost alternative and not to be seen as a competitor to its more tech-savvy rival. So friends ! if they are able to cach the Indian entertainment market and for that matter the whole of the developing world, they have a winner in their hands.

I'm sticking with dvds

First of all, I have happily been watching BD movies since the purchase of my PS3 (which is whole other bag of good stuff altogether).

I have an HDTV and would like to squeeze the most out of that purchase. It makes sense to have as many options as possible to make that HDTV purchase worthwhile. Secondly, the BD discs are more durable. If you have children (even if you don't) you know how easily the discs become scratched and even unplayable. All of my BDs look pristine because of the protective layer.
These are only practical reasons I've mentioned. There's also the fact that movies DO look far superior to their regular DVD counterparts even when upscaled.

Now, there's nothing wrong with DVD if you don't plan on getting a high-definition monitor or audio equipment. But for those of us who do, and the numbers will only grow with time, BR is the future and will be for some time.

If it ain't broken don't try to fix it. Whats wrong with DVD. Both BR and HD require HDTV which until they sort out the price of these then BR and HD will have trouble selling. Another format will probably come out in the next few years that ticks all the boxes and blows these 2 out of the water. If you put DVD up on the voting buttons I would guess that most of the people would be happy sticking with what they have at reasonable costs. DVD is not dead by a long shot yet.

HDTVs are selling. Maybe you don't have one but more households are picking them up every single day. New formats are inevitable. Happened to VHS, LaserDisc, DVD and it'll happen to BD someday, too. Just like game consoles upgrade every few years.

it seems that BR win HD its several advantages:
1,the monolayer capability of BR is 25GB,while HD is 15GB,and the Double-decked capacity of BR is 50GB,bigger than HD 'S 30GB
2,ps3 are made by BR which is so popular and HD has lost a good chance.and SONY pay more to movie company and BD win another good chance
3,HD can be produced by the same way like DVD,so it is easy to be pirated,but BD is no so easy to be pirated
ok,no matter you buy CD,VCD,DVD,Blu-ray or HD-DVD,there is a good tool to repair the scratches on them--discrepair machine.this is a new and large industry, more and more cds and dvds are used, however most people do not know they can be repaired when scratched, so have to throw away, that is one huge loss, they just need to pay less money to buy one disc repair machine,then many discs are saved,it is very worthy.especially for dvd rental stores...
our company has been on developing the discrepair machines for more than 7 years,developed several models--Disc Buddy,SY7,SY4,SY5 and so on.our purpose is to improve the machine quality and reduce its price--lowest price of these machines is just 80 USD,the highest price is no more than 700 USD,up to now,we have many distributors in ASIA,EURO,UK,AMERICA,AUSTRALIA.
IF YOU ARE INTERESTED,PLS FEEL FREELY TO CONTACT me,send emails to ho nghongsun@hotmail.com or overview our website:www.discrepair.com.cn or you can call my mobile phone :(00)86 (0)371 15903666354

A Big waste of money!! I've seen both of them Nothing is different they're both the same! I'm sticking with the DVD's I have now. There's no point in switching! It's not like an "8 track"!!

I will just wait!

بر درگه آن شهان نهادندی روی
دیدم که بر کنگرهاش فاخته ای
بنشسته همی گفت که کوکو کوکو
خیام

عرب ها جغد هایی هستند که ناله کوکو کوکو می کنند

Yea Buddy!

why should we have to send more money t0 change our movie collections so some one else can make more money. Get over it. ps

patricia-
you don't have to do that. it's the most ludicrous argument ever. When a studio reissues a movie as some Ultimate Collector's Edition Super-Duper Whatever are you compelled to purchase it (it's called "Double Dipping," by the way).

It seems for most people who own BR, they plan to purchase titles that they don't have and the ones that are yet to be made yet. Some will upgrade their old ones and that's their coin.

I'v seen HD DVD and I'v seen Blu-ray and Blu-ray has won me over.

Blu-ray already won, but maybe HD can come back from the dead!!!

Sorry Joe C but slysoft have made all bluray BD+ all ready out there crack even hitman. And for copie is piracy this is the disclaimer of ERAGON french version. I just look at the disclaimer from ERAGON bluray, in the french version of disclaimer say" interdit Tout reproduction sauf pour l'usage strictement privé du copiste " That meen that you can do a copie off it if it's for your self. So it make it perfectly legal to do so in CANADA at lease.

come on man lets go with HD

Hannah Montana Goes 3-D with 'Best of Both Worlds Concert Tour'Tech specs reveal Disney's plans to present a first-ever 3-D Viewing Mode on the disc, along with a 2-D version as well, both in 1080p video. Audio boasts uncompressed PCM 7.1 Surround audio. I really want to know if you need a tv that is 3d capable or they going to put out those 3d blu ray players

Here is an interesting read from Reuters. The concern doesn't appear to be with how fast blu-ray adoption is (10%) now, but on how many TVs are high def capable. Bluray has crossed the 10 million mark, which is around 10% of the 113.9 million households in the US.
http ://www.reuters.com/article/technolog...< /a>

I thought Blu-ray already won. Thats what it said in the Fort Worth Texas Star Telegram anyways. Please up date this survey.

??? i tought that blu-ray already destroyed hd dvd!!

Page 3.already bluray alone is 6% against DVD
http://www.n xtbook.com/nxtbooks/questex/...

x-box360 PS3 Nintendo Wii All three thrive in our market. HD DVD BLU-RAY one has to die! I don't understand that at all. people are buying blu-ray even though they would rather have HD-DVD.

@ Joe C.
-
I offered side by side reviews of dual format releases back one page from a format neutral website. Enjoy!

You only showed a limited view. Please check out this debate between Dobyblue and others on picture & sound quality. These are some stats from not just Highdef digest, but 4 other independent review sites of over 2000 reviews in total and he gives the stats not just by review sites but by studio as well. These stats were as of the mid 4th quarter 2007, and since then have climbed in blu-rays favor even more because of advances in compression engineering.
http ://www.shootfortheedit.com/forum/sho...< /a>
It shows both audio and video review ratings of both bluray and hddvd. It is an interesting but educational debate. Follow it for several pages or at least until this page where you start to see why blu-ray video is better overall because of using more AVC encodes which use higher bit rate spiking and less compression overall. Although VC-1 is doing much better lately since they started lowering the compression and increasing the overal throughput to get better picture quality. lower compression means more disc space used & higher throughput needed of course, which bluray can do this because of their initial specs on dics space and bit rate throughput.
http ://www.shootfortheedit.com/forum/sho...< /a>
You really would find it interesting to converse with a compression engineer or even someone like Dobyblue over at
www.blu-ray.com< /a> sometime. These guys are very knowledgeable and people can learn much more from them than our little debates on here. They are the real pros, that dispelled the FUD from AMIR and RDJAM over at AVS forums. But if nothing else just go to the insiders forum and talk to some of these compression engineers who have worked on both hddvd and bluray encodes, but also if you want to learn stats on this stuff, talk with Dobyblue or countless others. They have more links and stats than you can imagine, and if you check out their sources and stats for yourself you will see that they are true to form.

macys.com
American Express
Loading People...